The prime video show thrilled me and many other viewers with its stellar adaptation of The Killing Floor in season one, and the amazing cast they gathered for it. The show skipped nine books for its sophomore season by adapting book 11 Bad Luck and Trouble. They also brought in Serinda Swan (Devotion, Inhuman), Robert Patrick (The Night Agent, Peacemaker, Perry Mason), Shaun Sipos (Krypton, The Vampire Diaries), Ferdinand Kingsley, and Domenick Lombardozzi (Mrs. Fletcher, Daredevil) among others to join Alan Ritchson and Maria Sten (Big Sky, Swamp Thing).

Last season Jack Reacher, a veteran military police investigator, is a drifter, carrying no phone and the barest of essentials as he travels and explores the nation he once served. While visiting the (fictional) rural town of Margrave, Georgia, Reacher is arrested for murder. After he is freed, he teams up with two honest police officers, Oscar Finlay (Malcolm Goodwin), and Roscoe Conklin (Willa Fitzgerald), to investigate a local conspiracy.

This season picks up 2 years 7 months and 19 days after Margate, Reacher, and Neagley investigate the murder of a member of 110th, a group of Special investigators assembled by Reacher, only to realize the whole unit may be at risk.

Season two manages to capture the essence of Lee Child‘s Bad Luck and Trouble while introducing refreshing elements that keep both fans of the books and newcomers intrigued. Set against new backdrops (New York & New Jersey) this season brings a unique feel to the narrative, colder and darker, creating an engaging experience for viewers.

One notable aspect of these refreshing elements is the early inclusion of Frances Neagley played by Sten. When I watched season one of Reacher, I was only familiar with the first book in the series but I knew that Neagley appeared in later books. So my first encounter with her book counterpart was in Bad Luck and Trouble however her inclusion in the first season of the show was genius. I like it even more now because it adds an extra layer of familiarity and connectivity to both seasons. Neagley, in season one, was the remaining connection to his military career past when most past information on Reacher was focused on his personal family life before the military. This season Neagley is the bridge to learning more about his career within the Military Police Corps.
The casting choices, the performances, and the writing – particularly for Detective Russo (Lombardozzi) or even Calvin Franz (Luke Bilyk) – strike the perfect balance, making the distinction between a good guy and a potentially corrupt individual palpable. The Show seamlessly integrates changes, both in location and character dynamics, which not only make sense for the visual medium but also enhance the storytelling.

The Show’s ability to repurpose scenes from the source material and still maintain excitement showcases the creativity and adaptability of the writing team. I loved the nod to pop culture fans by the inclusion of a Sarah Connor reference with Robert Patrick in the cast.

As someone who often picks up quotes from all the media that I consume, I enjoyed the incorporation of quotes from Lee Child’s Book into the dialogue, such as the utilization of lines like: “Now they broke my toothbrush, I don’t own anything” and “Slippery slope. I carry a spare shirt, pretty soon I’m carrying spare pants. Then I’d need a suitcase. Next thing I know, I’ve got a house and a car and a savings plan and I’m filling out all kinds of forms.” both brilliantly delivered by Ritchson. It adds a layer of authenticity to the TV series and contributes to the overall connection between the show and the books.

As great as the action sequences are in the show, some viewers – like me – may find some elements of the helicopter fight sequence to be pushing the boundaries of realism. While Reacher’s action scenes are generally appreciated for their grounded nature, this particular instance may be seen as pushing it and a departure from Jack Reacher’s more plausible feats.

Despite this minor critique, Season 2 beautifully balances being both a prequel and a sequel, offering insights into Reacher’s military career, and depicting his transformation from a special investigator to a solitary drifter. The season successfully captures the spirit of the iconic characters and the book it’s based on while introducing new elements to keep the story fresh. The seamless blend of adaptation and innovation, coupled with strong casting choices makes it a worthy addition to the Reacher series. Fans of the books and the first season alike will find much to enjoy in this engaging and well-crafted installment.

If you want to support this site, help by getting me a coffee from the link below: